...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
Attendees & Representation
...
| Representative | Organization | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
Deutsche Telekom AG | TSC Chair, Active Maintainer | x | |
Deutsche Telekom AG | Active Maintainer | x | |
Ericsson | Active Maintainer | x | |
KDDI | Active Maintainer | x | |
Orange | TSC Deputy Chair, Active Maintainer | x | |
Radisys | EUC Representative | ||
Summit Tech | EUC Representative | x | |
Telefonica | Active Maintainer | x | |
Telefónica | Active Maintainer | x | |
Verizon | EUC Representative | ||
Vodafone | TSC Deputy Chair | x | |
Vodafone | Active Maintainer | x | |
| Chris Howell | Vonage | Active Maintainer | |
| George Glass | TM Forum | TM Forum Representative | |
| Olta Vangjeli | TM Forum | TM Forum Representative | x |
GSMA | GSMA Representative | x | |
GSMA | GSMA Representative | x | |
Airtel | Active Maintainer |
...
Community: Tanja de Groot Rafal Artych Lazlo Suto Markus Kümmerle Ravi Shekar Nick Venezia Pierre Close Toyeeb Rehman Aleksandar Brankovic Ricardo Serrano Gutierrez Ramesh Shanmugasundaram Ramit Chawla (airtel)
Agenda
The project's Antitrust Policy, which you can find linked from the LF and project websites. The policy is important where multiple companies, including potential industry competitors, are participating in meetings. Please review and if you have any questions, please contact your company legal counsel. Members of the LF may contact Andrew Updegrove at the firm Gesmer Updegrove LLP, which provides legal counsel to the LF. |
...
- Short recap from MWC (Markus Kümmerle)
- Slide deck presented by Markus (to be added here)
View file name MWC2024_Impressions.pdf height 150 - OpenGateway was one of the buzz word
- Monday Meet & Greet - good to meet even if the room was too far & small.
- The Tuesday event was great (Thanks to the sponsors Red Hat & Telefonica). 100+ people showed up with analyst, application developer, etc...
- Wednesday DefCon with TMF was also very successful. Markus should be know as the 'Godfather of Camara'. Thanks for the GSMA for the work in Glomo award.
- Henry added that the majority of DevCon attendee were developers. (around 120 developer for around 240 attendees).
- 48 developers participated to the hackathon.
- Henry will send attendance list information for DevCon & Hackathon (UPDATE: see Henry's message about MWC Open Gateway TopLine Stats)
- Slide deck presented by Markus (to be added here)
- Status of EasyCLA introduction (Casey Cain )
- EasyCLA activation scheduled for March 11th (as agreed in TSC Feb 15th)
- Casey provided links
- LFX Insights | Enhance data-driven collaboration management (linuxfoundation.org) to check LF project status
- https://docs.linuxfoundation.org/v2/easycla/corporate-cla-managers CLA Managers
- Casey provided links
- Open Office Hours (Casey Cain to provide)
- Several companies has already signed but they some are some still missing.
- Herbert is working with LF team on a step-wise introduction (starting with selected repositories).
- EasyCLA activation scheduled for March 11th (as agreed in TSC Feb 15th)
API Backlog (Ricardo Serrano Gutierrez )
- Proposal owner asked to postpone the two proposals from https://lists.camaraproject.org/g/tsc/message/139 to next TSC.
- Need additional work to harmonize both proposal.
- Info about Network Slice Booking (Herbert):
- Thorsten Lohmar (Ericsson) joining as additional maintainers
and Ricardo Serrano (Telefonica)(After internal alignment Ricardo will only be joining as additional maintainers contributor) (cf. https://github.com/camaraproject/NetworkSliceBooking/pull/1)- Reminder: Maintainers for new sub projects will be initially nominated/approved by the TSC
- First regular meeting will be on March 15th, 16:30 Beijing Time (8:30 UTC, 9:30 CET), details will be on wiki page of Network Slice Booking Maintainer will be nominated by the TSC.Draft
- Thorsten Lohmar (Ericsson) joining as additional maintainers
Commonalities (Rafal Artych )
- Issue #133 Adopt RFC 9457 error response format
- Slides presented by Lyle Bertz within Commonalities working group: 20240304-CAMARA-Issue 133 - RFC 9457 URN Option.pdf
- The issue will be closed with opening 2 more detailed issues for discussion in Commonalities:
- Adding a parameter to the current response format that would provide link to detailed error documentation
- Adopting RFC 9457 for error response format →Adopting RFC 9457 for Error Handling · Issue #157 · camaraproject/Commonalities (github.com). This is a 'burning' issue in term of impact of on a CAMARA wide release.
- Herbert Damker indicated that companies have to interact on these if they want a change
- to RFC 9457 by expressing their support within Issue #157 thread prior to the next Commonalities meeting [updated based on a suggestion received to clarify the needed action], else the current motion is to keep the current format and improve it gradually
- Issue #149 Consolidated issue for subscription discussion
- the list of issues, based on previous discussions in Commonalities and subprojects
- separated issues will be created to discuss each topic
- will have impact on all APIs which have or plan to have explicit subscriptions
- Issue #127 Which error send back when Device Identifier not supported by API Server? includes questions on
Deviceidentification:- when another identifier is present in Access Token
- when multiple contradictory identifiers are provided
- what identifier should be mandatory or optional - Aggregator use case → Should be discussed but we need to have another issue to discuss this.
- Rename the issue to avoid confusion (Ludovic Robert ) and continue to explore UCuse cases.
- Jose Luis Urien Pinedo reminded that the device model cames from QoD and was not challenged by other projects.
- Create a new issue about device identifier management/interoperability (diego.gonzalezmartinez ). Mark Cornall agrees on the criticality of this point regarding interoperability.
- Rename the issue to avoid confusion (Ludovic Robert ) and continue to explore UCuse cases.
...
- Herbert Damker provided update We on behalf of Axel
- The working group agreed to concentrate our the work on on https://github.com/camaraproject/IdentityAndConsentManagement/pull/121
- hot Hot topics: Offline Access and Refresh Tokens (under review - will got planned to get in the profile), Purpose (have a dedicated parameter vs keep it is the scope as of today), Pairwise Pseudonymous Identifiers
- Other points will be delayed to future release
- To keep the discussion on PRs more focused we the working group agreed to create new issues for controversial discussion points.
Release Management (tbc: Samuel Adeyemo )
- Initial infos by Herbert Damker (as Samuel isn't able to join)
- Release Process
- Release process will contain about 17-22 weeks
- Target to have first meta release in September => we have soon to kick-off
- Use Open Source Summit event in Vienna (16-18 September 2024) as target to announce the release
- Good timing to have API implementation available for MWC25
- first First milestones will include definition of Commonalities & ICM releases
- more More details with a review of the release process and milestones within next TSC
- Lyle Bertz informed the CAMARA board that TMUS is working on a replacement for Marouane Balmakhtar as community release manager
- Looking for (additional) volunteer for this the release management project .and as Community Release manager
- Release Process
GSMA certification of CAMARA APIs (Mark Cornall Toyeeb Rehman )
- Certification of 'live' implementation.
- Deck to be added here
- Toyeeb Rehman went from implementations (26 in sum tested)
View file name CAMARA TSC presentation - Common Testing Issues.pdf height 150 - Toyeeb Rehman presented the major issues faced during certification, including action points requested from TSC and its working groups
- Need larger diffusion because great work
- We need to have follow-up & tracking on this
Any Other Topic
- ...None due to lack of time
Next Meeting
- Next TSC Meeting will be on March 21st, 16:00 CET / 15:00 UTC / 07:00 PT
- Herbert Damker will not be available, Ludovic Robert will moderate
- Specific agenda topics:
- ...Update from TMForum collaboration and how members are working in Catalysts and Operate APIs (as proposed by Olta Vangjeli within comments)