Date

Jul 16, 2024

Attendees & Representation

Community:  @Jose Luis Urien Pinedo @Cetin Alpaycetin @Ludovic Robert @Fernando Prado Cabrillo @Surajj Jaggernath @Joachim Dahlgren @Javier Carro @Akos Hunyadi @Rafal Artych 

Agenda

Antitrust Policy

• Approve previous meeting minutes

  • Approved?

• Open issues and PRs

Minutes

Meta release (Fall24)

Schedule

• M3 by July 21st

  • First RC to be published 

  • This is not a hard deadline. Subprojects may reduce the period between M3 and M4

• M4 by August 31st

  • Hard deadline to have all final contents for meta-release approved

• Actions towards M3:

  Type your task here, using "@" to assign to a user and "//" to select a due date

Functionality

• Add handling when the requested geofence area cannot be covered

  • Waiting for Commonalities

    • Proposal: We can apply the proposal described in Commonalities (here)

      • adding a new termination reason

      • adding a new attribute to provide rational

      • Owner: @Maximilian Laue Jul 26, 2024 

• Update maxAge-behaviour for /verify & /retrieve

  • Review comments in issue

  • Decide on 422 vs 200 + UNKNOWN

    • Proposal: Move to option 1

    • Owner: @Maximilian Laue but @Jose Luis Urien Pinedo will provide suggestion in the PR Jul 26, 2024 

Alignment with Commonalities

Errors

• geofencing: Alignment of errors with Commonalities

  • 1 approval

  • 1 comment suggesting to not include all possible HTTP codes. This issue was also discussed in QoD

  • Proposal:

    • We align Geofencing with QoD

      • Owner: @Maximilian Laue Jul 26, 2024 

    • It can cause some misalignment with Commonalities but we can fix it in Commonalities later.

• https://github.com/camaraproject/QualityOnDemand/issues/305location-retrieval: Alignment of errors with Commonalities

  • 1 approval with comments

  • Action: @Jose Luis Urien Pinedo approve it and merge it by Jul 16, 2024 

• location-verification: Alignment of errors with Commonalities

  • 2 approvals

  • Merged

New: device input

• Align device object with Guidelines

  • Make device optional

  • Add some new doc to info.description

  • Exception: In Geofencing we keep the device object mandatory.

Test plans

All with some comments, still not approved:

• Testing plan for location verification

• Geofencing feature file

• Add Test Definition for location Retrieval

• Action: @Jose Luis Urien Pinedo @Ludovic Robert Close the review and merge them before Jul 19, 2024 for Location Verification & Location Retrieval

  • Ask review from @Toyeeb Rehman 

API readiness checks

Common issue: Provide API readiness checklist

• Proposal to upgrade location-verification API to first stable relase (v1.0.0) as it is the only one that fulfills the requirement to have a previous public release certified

  • Discuss if there are objections

  • No objection

• Requires 3 files, one per API

  • PR for location-verification: Create Location Verification API readiness checklist

  • Action:

    • We create independent PR for

      • location-retrieval - owner @Ludovic Robert Jul 19, 2024 

      • Geofencing  - owner @Maximilian Laue Jul 26, 2024 

• One of the checks is to add a link to the User Stories:

  • PR for location-verification: location-verification Create Location Verification User Story

• Discuss on how we manage to add all meta data for the 3 APIs: Create PRs for each change, keep PR open until everything is OK....

  • Proposal: We create them as Draft - we sync when we need to merge to block ourselves when owner are on leave.

Scopes for meta-release

• Issues created and linked in DeviceLocation API Release Tracking

  • Scope of Location Verification API for Fall24 CAMARA Meta Release

  • Scope of Location-Retrieval for Fall24 CAMARA Release

  • Scope of Geofencing Subscriptions API for Fall24 CAMARA Meta Release

• Review if we need to update anything

Other New

• Issue: Add an “Area” data-type into CAMARA_common.yaml

  • Referencing Commonalities issue 

Ongoing (not for Meta-release)

• Polygon area type added

  • PR195

Action items