2024-03-04 Commonalities WG Minutes

Attendees & Representation

Type @ and your name to indicate your attendance

LF Staff:

Community: @Ming Hui Foo @Ludovic Robert @Eric Murray @Pierre Close @Lyle Bertz @G. Murat Karabulut @Former user (Deleted) @Mark Cornall @Sachin kumar @Rafal Artych @Herbert Damker  Toyeeb Rehman @Pedro Díez García 

Agenda

• Roll Call

• Action Items Review

• Agenda Bashing

• General Topics
  
  

  • Merged PRs

  • Discussions in Github repository

  • Pull Requests review

  • Issues review

  • Any Other Topics

• Any Other Topics

Minutes

Action Item Review

Merged PRs

• PR #131 Update API-design-guidelines to add subscriptionMaxEvents

• PR #146 Update README.md with meeting details on th LF Platform

Current Discussions

• Clarification on 'subscriptionExpireTime' and 'expiresAt' Handling

  • Clarifications added by @Ludovic Robert 

PRs review

• PR #120 Update CAMARA_common.yaml: add Device headers, fix address

  • To be checked internally by Telefonica

• PR #143 Update Design Guidelines with character set guidance

  • More reviews expected

• PR #145 Added 501 Not Supported error response

  • PR was explained by @Ming Hui Foo 

  • The proposed error message is for phone number parameter  when the service is not supported for given phone number

  • Another error messages can be needed for other device identifiers

• PR #148 Mandate '+' in all phoneNumber formats

  • PRoposed changes in API Design Guidelines, CAMARA_common.yaml and Glossary

  • More reviews expected

• PR #152 Update API Design Guidelines on usage and style of operation tags

  • More reviews expected

Issues review

• Issue #149 Consolidated issue for subscription discussion

  • @Former user (Deleted) presented the list of issues, based on previous discussions in Commonalities and subprojects

  • Separated issues will be created to discuss each topic

• New issues related to Authcontext  - CloudEvents extension

  • Issue #150 Using CloudEvents extension Authcontext for certain event types

  • Issue #151 Copy CloudEvents extension Authcontext also for explicit subscriptions

• Issue #133 Adopt RFC 9457 error response format

  • Slides presented by @Lyle Bertz : 20240304-CAMARA-Issue 133 - RFC 9457 URN Option.pdf

  • The issue will be closed with opening 2 more detailed issues:

    • Adding a parameter to the current response format that would provide link to detailed error documentation

    • Adopting RFC 9457 for error response format

• Issue #127 Which error send back when Device Identifier not supported by API Server?

  • The discussion should go back to the questions raised in @Jose Luis Urien Pinedo comment: https://github.com/camaraproject/Commonalities/issues/127#issuecomment-1966313547

  • For other topics separate issue can be opened if needed

AOB

The next meeting is on Mar 25th 2024 (shifted from 18th) using https://zoom-lfx.platform.linuxfoundation.org/meeting/91016460698?password=d031b0e3-8d49-49ae-958f-af3213b1e547

The meeting on April 1st 2024 is cancelled.

Action items