2024-05-17 Quality on Demand - Meeting Minutes

Attendees & Representation

Type @ and your name to indicate your attendance

LF Staff: na

Community: @Herbert Damker @efezhan @Eric Murray @Joachim Dahlgren @Jose Luis Urien Pinedo@Randy Levensalor @Surajj Jaggernath @Toshi Wakayama @Rafal Artych  @Patrice Conil @Thorsten Lohmar @dominik.fischer @Masaharu Hattori @Ramesh Shanmugasundaram @Maximilian Laue @Jorge Garcia Hospital, CHINTAN LODARIYA

Agenda

• Antitrust Policy

• Review of previous meeting minutes

• Overall Topics

• Regular Topics

  • Open Pull Requests

  • New Issues

  • Issues relevant for v0.11.0

• Any Other Topics

Minutes

Review of previous meeting minutes

• Previous meeting minutes: 2024-05-03 Quality on Demand - Meeting Minutes

  • No comments, agreed to remove "DRAFT"

Overall topics

• New GitHub teams @camaraproject/quality-on-demand_maintainers and @camaraproject/quality-on-demand_codeowners are complete.

• TSC: Reactivated discussion Commonalities/issues/171: Revise the device object definition to simplify it 

  • Telefonica team will set up a dedicated meeting, involving ICM & Commonalities team

  • Who from Qod will participate? 

    • @Jose Luis Urien Pinedo obviously ... PhoneNumber yes, IP Address in some cases, Network Access Identifier not yet. To be discussed in which cases the Device object can be made optional (e.g. if already contained in access token)

    • @Randy Levensalor to ensure that fixed wireless access will be considered

  • Based on outcome we will enhance our description when to use and how to use the device object

Open Pull Requests

• PR #289 Split QoD in Quality-On-Demand and QoS Profiles APIs by @Jose Luis Urien Pinedo 

  • Open comments resolved and PR merged

• PR #294 Update README.md by @Jorge Garcia Hospital 

  • Open comments resolved online, ready for final review

Closed issues

• #290 Current CI expects certain fixed name for yaml spec

• #265 Proposal to split QoS Sessions and QoS Profiles into two separate API definitions

  • fixed with merged PR #289 

New Issues

• none

Issues relevant for v0.11.0

• #292 Scope of QualityOnDemand for Fall24 CAMARA release

  • No updates, still valid

• #291 Consolidated issue for duration, extentDuration, startedAt, expiredAt, maxDuration and their formats (to be updated)

  • Covers also #288, #281, #280, #266, #249

  • @Jose Luis Urien Pinedo will make first proposal

  • Previous minutes

    • discussed about maxDuration → establish again as absolute maximum

    • discussed about default for duration 

      • making duration parameter mandatory could be an option

• #257 Error behaviour when session cannot be created due to "time cap" limitation

  • Will be addressed after PR #289 is merged

• #245 Update and enhance test definition file for QOD API

  • Telefonica has a feature file for testing, will adapt it to Commonalities results, and then contribute.

  • Commonalities PR #203 with design guidelines for .feature files and test coverage (sunny/rainy test cases). For first meta-release the full coverage will not be required.

    • CAMARA test cases will only test the correct reactions of the API, not the service (e.g. network performance or SLAs)

  • Previous content:
    
    

    • Sunny test cases have to added before first release candidate of v0.11.0 (mid of June)

• #244 Align securitySchemes and security of QOD API spec with IdentityAndConsentManagement

  • @Eric Murray will create a PR. 

• #166 Extend QoS Profile queries to list profiles based on specific users or devices

  • @Randy Levensalor  will create a first PR

• #101 List endpoint for active sessions of authenticated user

  • Please review latest proposal on this issue: https://github.com/camaraproject/QualityOnDemand/issues/101#issuecomment-2015041284

  • Draft PR #228 need to be closed and restarted due to the split and based on the discussion.

Further Issues

• #268 Provision mode for QoD

  • It would be good to have an user story to get a better understanding of the Provision mode usage and behaviour

  • @Jose Luis Urien Pinedo: the Provision mode will be proposed as independent API, 90% same as Session mode API

  • @Thorsten Lohmar asked for answers to his questions in https://github.com/camaraproject/QualityOnDemand/issues/268#issuecomment-2079239521

• #286 Review Attribute Descriptions with References to External Specifc

  • No update, previous content: 

    • @Herbert Damker check where QoD would be impacted 

    • Maybe into backlog until implementation experiences are available

Any other topics

• Next QoD meeting will be on May 31st, at 14:00 CEST / 12:00 UTC

• Herbert will be on vacation. Meeting will be moderated by @Randy Levensalor 

Action items